top of page

DRIP PRICING IN FASHION RESALE: FEES,LAWSUITS AND UNANSWERED QUESTIONS

12 minutes ago
9 min read

Drip Pricing in Fashion Resale: Fees, Lawsuits and Unanswered Questions

Earlier this year, I wrote about a lawsuit challenging The RealReal’s return shipping and processing fee. I have continued to follow the broader issue of drip pricing: when a listed price excludes additional charges that appear as a shopper moves through a purchase.


On September 15, 2026, Javier Rivera filed a proposed class action against Depop over its marketplace fee. He alleges that excluding the fee from listed prices makes it harder for shoppers to compare Depop with other marketplaces and retailers. His complaint follows an earlier federal lawsuit against Depop filed by Linsey Dinh in February 2026.


There have also been developments in other cases. The RealReal case was voluntarily dismissed in January 2026. In a separate StockX case, an October 2025 ruling allowed a pricing challenge to proceed despite the company’s argument that the buyer saw the fee before completing his purchase. More recently, a September 8, 2026 ruling involving Williams-Sonoma, a retailer not in the resale industry, addressed whether customers challenging a combined shipping and processing fee had to pursue their claims through arbitration. These developments offer useful distinctions for buyers, sellers and marketplace operators, even though they have not produced a final answer governing every resale fee.


What Is Drip Pricing?

Drip pricing occurs when a business initially shows only part of the required purchase price and then reveals additional charges later in the transaction. Both the amount of a fee and the timing of its disclosure matter. A shopper may spend time inspecting photographs, reviewing measurements and comparing listings before seeing that a mandatory fee increases the cost. The buyer then has to decide whether to accept the higher total, reconsider other listings or not complete the purchase.


California’s Honest Pricing Law, effective July 1, 2024, generally requires listed prices to include mandatory charges, with exceptions including certain government charges and qualifying shipping costs for physical goods. The shipping exception covers transportation costs reasonably and actually incurred to ship the goods to the customer. The Attorney General’s guidance does not give a dollar limit. It distinguishes those delivery costs from mandatory handling charges, which must be included in the listed price. The law governs price transparency rather than setting the amount a business may charge.

 

Depop: Another Challenge to Its Marketplace Fee

In his September 15, 2026 complaint, filed in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Illinois, Rivera alleges he purchased an item listed at $400 in August 2025. According to reporting on the complaint, the transaction included $7.99 in shipping, $43.94 in sales tax and a $20.70 marketplace fee, bringing the final total to $472.63. He alleges that the fee appeared only on the final payment screen and that he did not notice it until after purchasing. Rivera says earlier disclosure would have affected his decision. His complaint brings claims under Illinois consumer protection law and for unjust enrichment, seeking relief for a proposed nationwide class and an Illinois subclass. These remain allegations.

A November 2, 2026 court entry extended Depop’s deadline to answer or otherwise respond until December 7. Note that is a scheduling development, rand not a decision on whether its fee disclosures were lawful. The substantive issue concerns the price shoppers see before reaching the final payment stage.

 

Depop’s published policy says its U.S. Marketplace Fee took effect on July 18, 2024. It is calculated at up to 5% of the item purchase price, plus a fixed amount of up to $1, excluding shipping and taxes. The policy says the exact amount will be shown during checkout and describes the fee as supporting buyer protection, customer service, platform improvements and community growth. It also says the fee is refunded in full when an item is refunded.

 

The connection to Rivera’s complaint is the timing. Depop’s policy tells buyers that the fee will be shown during checkout; Rivera challenges its omission from prices shown earlier. Explaining the calculation or purpose of a fee does not resolve that disagreement. The question is whether shoppers receive the required price information while comparing items and deciding where to buy, rather than after they have invested time in a particular purchase.


An Earlier Depop Complaint

Linsey Dinh filed her federal complaint in California on February 6, 2026. She alleged that a $17 purchase in January 2025 carried an additional $1.55 marketplace fee that was not included in the listed price. Her complaint referred to California consumer protection laws, including the prohibition on advertising prices that exclude required charges. The complaint documents an earlier challenge to the fee’s disclosure and it does not establish that its allegations were proven.

 

The different legal grounds matter. Dinh’s complaint relied on California law, while Rivera’s invokes Illinois law. A similar purchasing experience therefore raises different legal questions depending on the law being applied. For shoppers, the concern is whether the price used to compare a listing with alternatives includes the platform’s mandatory purchase fee.


StockX: Seeing the Fee Before Payment Was Not Enough to Dismiss the Case

On October 3, 2025, Judge Rita F. Lin denied StockX’s motion to dismiss the proposed class action Mansfield v. StockX LLC. Daniel Mansfield alleged StockX initially displayed an artificially low price for shoes and disclosed a processing fee later. StockX argued that he saw the fee before completing the transaction and purchased anyway. The court rejected the argument that this necessarily defeated a claim based on the earlier omission. The outcome was that the case could proceed. The court had not found StockX liable. 


That distinction helps explain the concern about late disclosure. A listed price can influence which marketplace a buyer visits, which items they consider and how much time they spend evaluating them. Showing the full amount before payment does not necessarily answer whether an earlier price misled the shopper. A customer may complete the transaction after discovering the fee while still believing that the initial comparison was incomplete. On

November 5, 2026, the court also denied StockX’s request to pause discovery deadlines while its motion to compel arbitration was pending, citing its delay in seeking the pause. That order did not decide the arbitration motion or the pricing claims. It addressed whether the exchange of information in the litigation should be put on hold.


StockX belongs in this discussion as a resale marketplace. Note though resale does not necessarily mean used. StockX's Verified Marketplace sells new, unworn goods, while its separate Listings Marketplace includes used items. The ruling describes a shoe purchase without establishing that the shoes were used.

 

Updating My Earlier Coverage of The RealReal

The case I previously discussed, Fadrigo v. The RealReal, began in California state court on July 30, 2025. The complaint challenged a $14.95 return shipping and processing fee. Fadrigo alleged that he was not informed of the fee when purchasing and was assessed when returning merchandise. He also disputed whether the amount corresponded to actual shipping costs or processing work. These were allegations about a cost encountered after the purchase, when the customer decided to return an item.

 

After the case moved to federal court in September 2025, The RealReal requested that the dispute be sent to arbitration. On January 12, 2026, Fadrigo filed a notice voluntarily dismissing the case with prejudice, which generally prevents him from bringing the same claims again. The docket does not explain his decision, establish a settlement or show a ruling granting arbitration before the dismissal. Therefore it does not answer why he ended the case or establish that the fee was lawful.

 

The RealReal fee differs from Depop’s Marketplace Fee because it is triggered by returning merchandise rather than completing a purchase. A buyer may never incur a return fee, but knowing about it can affect the decision to order an item that may not fit or meet expectations. Fadrigo belongs within the broader discussion of fee transparency, provided a contingent return cost is distinguished from a mandatory purchase fee.

 

Beyond Resale: Williams-Sonoma’s Shipping and Processing Dispute

A September 8, 2026 ruling in O’Malley v. Williams-Sonoma, Inc. adds a retail comparison. Plaintiffs Katie O’Malley and Megan Reilly allege that a bundled “Shipping & Processing Fee” appeared during checkout and that the processing portion should have been included in listed prices. Judge Rita F. Lin denied the company’s motion to compel arbitration.The ruling addressed its arbitration agreement, rather than deciding whether the pricing violated the law.


The agreement required coordinated claims to move through successive groups: initially 20 cases, followed by mediation, then 40 cases and further stages. Customers outside the selected group had to wait. The court found that this structure risked extreme delays and could deter customers from pursuing claims or finding counsel. This explains its concern that later claims could remain unresolved indefinitely.

 

An appeal was opened in the Ninth Circuit on September 22, 2026. The public appellate docket reviewed for this post records the appeal’s opening and initial briefing schedule and it does not establish an appellate decision.

 

The shipping distinction is relevant to resale buyers. A charge can combine delivery with another service, but the heading alone does not explain the components. California’s guidance distinguishes transportation costs from mandatory handling charges. A combined shipping and processing charge consequently raises the question of which costs are being excluded from the listed price. That helps explain the Williams-Sonoma allegations without treating the arbitration ruling as a decision on the fee itself.

 

Williams-Sonoma, StockX and The RealReal also sought to have customers’ disputes handled through arbitration. For shoppers, that means the terms can affect where a complaint is heard and the process for pursuing it. Understanding a fee and understanding how to challenge it are separate considerations, but both become relevant when a customer disputes a transaction.

 

What Resale Buyers Can Take From These Cases

These court cases so far have not produced one definitive answer governing every resale fee. They do reinforce the value of comparing the listed item price with the full amount required to purchase it, as well as checking any potential return costs. Comparing marketplaces at a similar stage of checkout can reveal differences that listing prices alone do not show.


Resale comparisons already require more work than matching prices for identical new products. Buyers typically are assessing wear, broken or missing parts such as buttons and belts, measurements, authenticity claims and processes seller history and return policies. A mandatory fee revealed late adds another variable after the buyer has evaluated those differences. It can change which listing is better without changing anything about the item itself.


Availability adds another complication. A buyer who finds a particular size, color or discontinued style may have few alternatives. After learning there is an additional fee, that shopper faces a choice between paying more for the item already found and risking that it sells while searching elsewhere. The item’s scarcity can make the buyer reluctant to walk away, even if the higher total would have affected the original search. That is one reason completing a purchase does not necessarily show that the timing of the fee disclosure made no difference.


Buyers who want to question a fee can save the listing, checkout breakdown and relevant policies so they can show what appeared at each stage. If a charge groups shipping, processing or protection together, asking what each component covers can also clarify the cost. A fee’s name alone does not establish whether it is lawful, but the explanation should help the customer understand the payment being requested.

 

What This Means for Marketplace Sellers and Resale Businesses

For those selling through peer-to-peer marketplaces, the platforms’ fees can affect how buyers perceive an asking price. The seller may control the listing price while the platform determines an additional buyer fee. During seller / buyer negotiations, the seller may be considering expected proceeds and the buyer the full checkout amount. That difference can influence offers and acceptance decisions even when both parties understand the item’s condition and value.


Marketplace operators determine how their platform charges appear. The concern raised in these lawsuits is that leaving a mandatory fee out of the initial price can distort comparisons and influence purchasing decisions before the full cost becomes clear. For operators focusing on attracting and keeping shoppers, improving search and encouraging listings, transparent prices are part of helping customers compare what is offered.


A resale business selling through its own website has more direct control over the purchasing experience. It can review how item prices, mandatory service charges, shipping and return costs are communicated across product pages, policies and checkout. Williams-Sonoma provides a comparison from conventional retail; its role differs from that of a seller using Depop. The relevant connection is the website operator’s control over what the customer sees and when.

 

So far, these cases have provided limited answers about the drip pricing practices being challenged. Some disputes have ended without a court deciding the pricing question, while others are still working through that process. There is reason to keep following them: future decisions could help clarify how businesses must communicate additional charges and when shoppers should see them.

 

In the meantime, buyers still have purchases to make, sellers have prices to set, and marketplaces have fees to explain. Knowing the full cost early enough to compare options remains important, even while the lawsuits are unresolved. For resale businesses, reviewing how charges appear across listings, policies and checkout is something they can do now.



Sources



Full Disclosure: This post reflects my opinions and observations and is intended for informational purposes only. It should not be taken as professional, financial, or legal advice. Lawsuit allegations should not be treated as proven facts. Case information reflects publicly available materials reviewed as of November 18, 2026. Public docket summaries may lag subsequent filings. I have a Depop account but have not bought or sold on the platform. I have consigned with The RealReal, and all transactions were handled satisfactorily. I have also purchased from the Williams-Sonoma’s website, and those transactions went smoothly. I was not paid to write this post. All images were created by ChatGPT.

Comments


  • Bluesky

© 2017 - 2026 by Pamela Tucker. All rights reserved.

bottom of page