CHANEL V. THE REALREAL LUXURY RESALE LAWSUIT: NOVEMBER 2026 UPDATE

Introduction
Just weeks after the Second Circuit affirmed the judgment in Chanel's lawsuit against What Goes Around Comes Around, a decision I wrote about in a post: Chanel v. What Goes Around Comes Around: The Authentication Provision That Caught My Attention, Chanel's other 2018 luxury resale lawsuit Chanel, Inc. v. The RealReal, Inc. moving forward again. Following a nearly three year pause and a failed settlement conference in March 2026, the federal court lifted the stay. Both parties are now working under a formal court schedule that sets April 15, 2027 as the cutoff for all non-expert discovery. In a November 16, 2026 letter to the court, The RealReal’s attorneys asked to resolve a dispute over documents tied to its surviving "unclean hands" defense before fact depositions begin, while Chanel has yet to produce those records as the judge weighs The RealReal's bid to revive its antitrust counterclaims.
Eight years after Chanel first sued the The RealReal, a resale / consignment platform in Manhattan federal court, the case now looks headed for a federal trial. It remains unclear whether Chanel v. The RealReal will set a broader precedent for the resale industry. Even in the final outcome of Chanel v. WGACA, the court did not resolve the broader issue over who is allowed to authenticate luxury goods. The permanent injunction in that case never established Chanel as the sole authenticator; instead, it left WGACA free to make authenticity claims as long as it maintains records of its own authentication to back them up. To understand what is actually at issue for resellers, consignors, and shoppers, it helps to trace how the case got to this point.
November 2018: How It Started
Chanel filed its original complaint in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York on November 14, 2018, followed by an amended complaint in February 2019. At the center of the lawsuit is a direct challenge to The RealReal's business model and marketing.
Chanel alleged that The RealReal sold counterfeit Chanel branded goods while marketing its inventory as "100% the real thing," "100% authenticated," and vetted by in-house "experts." The RealReal takes physical possession of items, prices them, and makes its own authentication guarantee a major selling point. Chanel argued that when fakes slip through under those promises, it amounts to trademark infringement, counterfeiting, false advertising, and unfair competition.
March 2020: The First Major Hurdle
The RealReal moved to dismiss the entire lawsuit, but on March 30, 2020, U.S. District Judge Vernon S. Broderick allowed Chanel's three core claims to survive: trademark counterfeiting and infringement, false advertising, and New York common law unfair competition. Specifically, the court found that Chanel had plausibly alleged that contrary to The RealReal's "100% authenticated" marketing, counterfeit bags had been sold on the platform.
2020–2025: The RealReal Fires Back and the Long Stays Begin
Instead of only contesting Chanel's allegations, The RealReal brought its own claims into the case. In October 2020 The RealReal asked the court to let it add counterclaims, and after getting approval, formally filed them in February 2021, accusing Chanel of violating federal antitrust laws and committing tortious interference.
The RealReal argued that Chanel was using illegal vertical agreements with retailers and media outlets to suppress secondary market competition and monopolize the market for Chanel goods, while selectively tolerating Chanel resale on Farfetch after making a significant investment in that platform in 2018. The RealReal also raised an affirmative defense known as "unclean hands." In other words, "unclean hands" is a legal doctrine arguing that a company suing for court ordered relief, like an injunction shouldn't be allowed to win if it has acted unfairly or in bad faith itself regarding the very market in dispute. Here, The RealReal is arguing that Chanel's own alleged efforts to restrict luxury resale should bar it from getting relief from the court.

Chanel promptly moved to dismiss those counterclaims and strike the "unclean hands" defense in March 2021. After that, the case moved slowly, interrupted by multiple stays.
April – November 2021 Magistrate Judge Gabriel W. Gorenstein granted a joint stay so the parties could pursue private mediation. After three full days of mediation failed to produce a deal, the stay was lifted in November 2021.
Late 2021 – Mid-2023 The case was back in active litigation. Both sides worked through discovery on Chanel's core counterfeiting claims while fighting over the scope of The RealReal's counterclaims.
July 2023 – Early 2026 At the parties' joint request, Judge Gorenstein approved a new stay on July 20, 2023, so they could attempt another round of mediation. That pause dragged on for more than two years of reported settlement talks, until Judge Gorenstein finally stepped in and pressed both sides to move one of the oldest cases on the docket forward.
2026: The Pause Ends and Counterclaims Fall
That judicial push broke the stalemate in March 2026. On March 5, Magistrate Judge Gorenstein held a settlement conference that failed to produce a deal. The next day, March 6, 2026, he lifted the stay on discovery.
Three weeks later, on March 26, 2026, Judge Broderick issued a significant ruling for Chanel, dismissing all five of The RealReal's antitrust and tortious interference counterclaims. The court ruled that The RealReal's core antitrust allegations, including claims that Chanel used agreements with retailers and media outlets to block The RealReal's business and advertising, were filed too late under the statute of limitations, that The RealReal failed to show harm to market wide competition rather than simple business loss, and that Chanel's relationship with Farfetch did not support an antitrust claim.
The ruling was not a complete loss for The RealReal. Judge Broderick denied Chanel's motion to strike its "unclean hands" defense, ruling that Chanel's motion was untimely.
While that defense will not allow The RealReal to collect antitrust damages, it keeps The RealReal's allegations about Chanel's anti resale conduct in the case as a defense against Chanel's claims. At the same time, The RealReal is still trying to revive its counterclaims. It filed a motion to amend on April 20, 2026, which Chanel formally opposed on May 15, and the request remains pending before Judge Broderick as of mid November 2026.

Why This Matters Now
With fact discovery working toward an April 2027 close, and expert discovery still to follow, the case keeps the focus on how resale platforms authenticate luxury goods and how far they can go in marketing those guarantees.
That connects directly to Chanel's other 2018 lawsuit. On November 3, 2026, the Second Circuit issued a summary order affirming the counterfeiting verdict and $4 million statutory damages award against What Goes Around Comes Around (WGACA), while leaving the permanent injunction in place. As I noted in my Chanel - WGACA post, a summary order does not create a binding rule for other courts, and the WGACA injunction still left room for the reseller to make authenticity claims backed by records of its own authentication.
Still, lawyers can point to that ruling, and the gap between Chanel's public stance on authentication and how federal courts treat resellers' internal processes is now directly at issue in Chanel v. The RealReal. Whether or not this case sets a binding precedent, the documents and testimony gathered in discovery over the coming months will help determine The RealReal's financial exposure and offer a clearer look at how courts evaluate authentication guarantees under trademark and false advertising law.
Sources
Chanel, Inc. v. The RealReal, Inc., Case No. 1:18-cv-10626 (S.D.N.Y.) — Case Docket (Justia) — Full federal docket, including the November 14, 2018 complaint, the 2021– 2023 stay orders, the April–May 2026 motion to amend filings, and The RealReal's November 16, 2026 letter to Magistrate Judge Gabriel W. Gorenstein (Document 517).
Chanel_Inc_v_The_RealReal_Inc__nysdce-18-10626__0517.0.pdf
Opinion & Order on Motion to Dismiss, Document 39 (March 30, 2020) — Justia Law — Judge Vernon S. Broderick's ruling allowing Chanel's trademark counterfeiting, false advertising, and unfair competition claims to proceed.
Order Lifting Stay, Document 412 (March 6, 2026) — Justia Dockets (PDF) — Court order following the lifting of the multi-year discovery stay.
Opinion & Order on Counterclaims and Unclean Hands, Document 422 (March 26, 2026) — Justia Law — Judge Broderick's decision dismissing The RealReal's five antitrust and tortious interference counterclaims while leaving its "unclean hands" defense intact.
Chanel, Inc. v. What Comes Around Goes Around LLC, Case No. 25-722 (2d Cir.) — Appellate Docket (Justia) — Second Circuit docket for Chanel's parallel luxury resale appeal.
Disclosure: This post reflects my personal opinions and observations about the cited court documents and publicly available reporting. It is intended for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal, financial, or other professional advice, or replace advice from a qualified professional. I have no professional relationship with Chanel or What Goes Around (WGACA), and I have not purchased from either company. I have consigned with The RealReal and all transactions were handled satisfactorily. I did not receive any
compensation for writing this post. The images were created using ChatGPT's AI tools and are illustrative, not photographs of actual people, products, or court proceedings.


Comments